Viewpoint: Bringing logistics and transportation back in house

It would be tough to add up the actual pages that the business-to-business press has written, printed, and posted on the advantages that a successful outsourcing relationship can bring to a logistics operation.

By ·

It would be tough to add up the actual pages that the business-to-business press has written, printed, and posted on the advantages that a successful outsourcing relationship can bring to a logistics operation. When a shipper fully understands his needs and a third-party logistics provider (3PL) is attentive and responsive to those needs, that partnership has the potential to result in service levels and cost savings that could make even the stingiest CFO crack a smile. In fact, the LM staff has, time and time again, revealed case study examples of just that scenario. It often starts with transportation costs spiraling out of control and ends with a 3PL stepping in to redesign the distribution network, bringing order to the kingdom.

The story we’ve yet to tell involves a shipper that’s wise enough, and confident enough, to admit when he’s made a bad outsourcing decision—and, in turn, bring logistics and transportation back in house. Enter Marcus Smith, manager of transportation procurement of Armstrong World Industries, a 150-year-old manufacturer of flooring, ceilings, and cabinets—and this year’s NASSTRAC Shipper of the Year. Armstrong’s bold success story begins on page 20. Smith will be the first to tell you that he still believes in the power of a properly outsourced arrangement, and his story certainly isn’t designed to bash 3PLs. Instead, what I liked most about Smith’s tale is that it represents a tight-knit logistics operation that fully understands its customer’s needs—and its diverse modal mix—and was ready to respond quickly when it realized that those needs weren’t being met.

In fact, it took Smith and company just under a year after they outsourced their transportation (January 2007) to realize that things weren’t going to pan out. “New carriers were just sprung on us,” Smith tells Contributing Editor John Schulz. “And as we got into the summer of 2007, it got very busy and the problems started magnifying.”
Complaints, late deliveries, and missed pick-ups mounted, and Armstrong customers told Smith that they wanted the familiar faces back in the cabs. According to Smith, it all boiled down to a failure by the 3PL to understand their customer requirements—and he’s willing to shoulder some of the blame.

“Perhaps we just didn’t properly communicate on the front end, or our 3PL failed to understand how critical the service was,” says Smith. But any way he sliced it, he and the logistics and transportation team knew the poor performance couldn’t continue. What unfolds in the cover story by Schulz is a step-by-step process that brings transportation and logistics, now one of Armstrong’s core competencies, back in house. Smith and company created a seven-person in-house transportation department that consists of three new hires along with four Armstrong employees who are familiar with the company’s processes and culture. And the results have been stunning.

“A good 3PL definitely serves a great purpose, and I still recommend them,” Smith adds. “We just have a business with a lot of specialized needs…and we’re better served being on the team internally.”


About the Author

Michael Levans, Group Editorial Director
Michael Levans is Group Editorial Director of Peerless Media’s Supply Chain Group of publications and websites including Logistics Management, Supply Chain Management Review, Modern Materials Handling, and Material Handling Product News. He’s a 23-year publishing veteran who started out at the Pittsburgh Press as a business reporter and has spent the last 17 years in the business-to-business press. He’s been covering the logistics and supply chain markets for the past seven years. You can reach him at [email protected]

Subscribe to Logistics Management Magazine!

Subscribe today. It's FREE!
Get timely insider information that you can use to better manage your entire logistics operation.
Start your FREE subscription today!

Article Topics

3PL · Logistics · Transportation · Viewpoint · All Topics
Latest Whitepaper
Improving Packaging: The Cost of Shipping Air is Going Up
Retailers and manufacturers that insist on using inefficient and sloppy packaging methods—oversized boxes, inefficient packaging, poorly constructed palletized contents—are paying for their mistakes in sharply higher freight rates. Pitt Ohio White Paper, Logistics White Paper, Dimensional Packaging
Download Today!
From the July 2016 Issue
While it’s currently a shippers market, the authors of this year’s report contend that we’ve entered a “period of transition” that will usher in a realignment of capacity, lower inventories, economic growth and “moderately higher” rates. It’s time to tighten the ties that bind.
2016 State of Logistics: Third-party logistics
2016 State of Logistics: Ocean freight
View More From this Issue
Subscribe to Our Email Newsletter
Sign up today to receive our FREE, weekly email newsletter!
Latest Webcast
Getting the most out of your 3PL relationship
Join Evan Armstrong, president of Armstrong & Associates, as he explains how creating a balanced portfolio of "Top 50" global and domestic partners can maximize efficiency and mitigate risk.
Register Today!
EDITORS' PICKS
Regional ports concentrate on growth and connectivity
With the Panama Canal expansion complete, ocean cargo gateways in the Caribbean are investing to...
Digital Reality Check
Just how close are we to the ideal digital supply network? Not as close as we might like to think....

Top 25 ports: West Coast continues to dominate
The Panama Canal expansion is set for late June and may soon be attracting more inbound vessel calls...
Port of Oakland launches smart phone apps for harbor truckers
Innovation uses Bluetooth, GPS to measure how long drivers wait for cargo