Environmental Services Sourcing: A Case Study


May 21, 2010 - SCMR Editorial

Environmental services is often considered to be ill suited for an enterprise-wide procurement and management approach. The reason given: it’s too specialized and difficult to measure. Yet the following real-life example from a large client illustrates the opportunity for applying an enterprise-wide approach to such a complex service.

This category of spending covers engineering and analytical services performed to ensure that government locations and businesses comply with all federal and local environmental protection regulations and laws, such as those concerning clean air, clean water, emissions reduction, the protection of sites such as Indian burial grounds, the protection of certain animal habitats, and so forth. Many organizations do not have experts in house to perform this function, and choose to contract with environmental services providers.

The environmental services industry in the United States is highly fragmented and competitive, encompassing several thousand companies with collective revenues in excess of $125 billion. Environmental services companies range in size from one-person operations to large corporations that are often diversified into engineering and construction services. Labor (including wages, contractors, and subcontractors) is the major cost component of these services.

The Client Situation

The client is a national organization with locations throughout the United States. Typically, environmental services managers at each location purchased environmental services locally. While meeting the needs of each individual site, this approach often led to different prices being paid for essentially the same services and impeded enterprise-wide management. Local purchasers also often relied on the same set of trusted incumbents time after time, rather than engaging a broader potential vendor pool. The key challenge for the team was determining how to leverage the organization’s buying power nationally while continuing to ensure quality deliverables at the local level.

Through extensive analysis, the team developed a comprehensive commodity profile, including both a quantitative analysis of spending patterns and a qualitative description of customer needs, as well as a thorough market analysis. Subject matter experts (SMEs) and other key stakeholders participated in the analysis and development of recommendations. Common outcomes were identified with enough flexibility to account for unique local requirements. The client also had a socio-economic goal of ensuring that small businesses providing environmental services at the local level would not be excluded from the new procurement process. For implementation, the team elected to pursue national contracts for each of the main types of environmental services, with provisions put in place to encourage small business participation.

Typically, individual client sites used statements of work that specified how the work would be performed and by what type of personnel—that is, the specific qualifications required. While most locations would agree on the outcomes required, there could be differences in the statements of work that contributed to the different prices paid by various locations. In transitioning to a new procurement strategy, one of the main concerns of the SMEs and stakeholders was how to ensure quality deliverables and outcomes once the transition had been made from local to national procurement. Therefore, a key element of the procurement process would be the development of a library of performance-based work statements that would ultimately be incorporated into national contracts. Under the plan, the quality of deliverables and outcomes would be monitored at the local level.

In order to reach the broadest competitive pool of vendors for the national requirements, the implementation team encouraged small businesses to pool together to increase their geographic coverage capabilities. Throughout the development of the procurement process, the company strived to provide as much information as possible to the vendor pool to encourage participation by all qualified service providers.

As part of the performance-based procurement process, quality assessment tools and metrics have been established for each of the main categories of work to be provided. Results are assessed at the conclusion of each project, with vendor payment contingent on successful outcomes.

15 Percent Savings and More

The first projects procured under the national contract approach yielded savings of approximately 15 percent. Going forward, the client expects that enterprise-wide procurement of environmental services through national contracts will facilitate analysis and comparisons of costs across locations and will improve spending management.



Subscribe to Logistics Management magazine

Subscribe today. It's FREE!
Get timely insider information that you can use to better manage your
entire logistics operation.
Start your FREE subscription today!

Recent Entries

The questions for the most recent Semiannual Economic Forecast, which was released last week, included: 1-has the strength of the U.S. dollar had a negative, negligible or positive impact on their organization’s profits?; 2-has the net impact of the depressed prices of oil and related commodities been negative, negligible, or positive for their organization’s profits; and 3-how would they characterize the combined impact of their organization’s profits on the strength of the U.S. dollar and the depressed prices of oil and related commodities.

The Department of Transportation’s Bureau of Transportation Statistics (BTS) reported this week that that U.S. trade with its North America Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) partners Canada and Mexico dropped 5.8 percent on an annual basis in March to $90.5 billion.

Shippers sourcing their goods out the Port of Oakland’s largest marine terminal will soon need to make an appointment drayage providers before their cargo is released.

U.S. Carloads fell 10.6 percent at 244,290, and intermodal containers and trailers were off 6.5 percent at 262,693.

Now that the deal, which had to clear several regulatory hurdles in multiple countries, is official, FedEx executives were able to speak a little bit more freely, albeit being somewhat guarded in regards to certain integration specifics at the same time.

Article Topics

News · Supply Chain · Procurement · Management · All topics

Comments

Post a comment
Commenting is not available in this channel entry.