Negotiating with Bullies

By Rosemary Coates, President of Blue Silk Consulting
July 07, 2014 - SCMR Editorial

I am in Singapore this week, teaching a Strategic Negotiations Workshop for the Asian Supply Chain (3PL) division of a global transportation company.  The class of about 20 Supply Chain Managers came from across Asia (Singapore, Malaysia, Japan, China, and Korea) to attend.  It was truly an honor to work with these very talented and extremely smart people.

But their frustration with Supply Chain and Logistics customers was palpable.  They told me story after story of negotiations that broke down because their customers were solely focused on reducing prices, including squeezing the last fractions of pennies out of 3PL services.  Customers have become bullies they said. Most of their customers are represented by buyers from headquarters assigned to the contracts; professional buyers with little or no understanding of Supply Chain strategies.  Very often these buyers have only one thing in mind: reducing prices and they won’t tolerate discussions about anything else.  They don’t see the bigger picture and don’t understand the value-added components of 3PL services.

My students were desperate for strategies and tactics to help them out of these “price reduction only” discussions with their customers and broaden the conversations.  We worked hard to develop some effective strategies for negotiating with buyers and bullies who focus on price only.  These include:

1. Every time a customer asks for another price reduction, suggest trading for something in return. Ask for something of value back such as move volume, another division, another project.  Never concede, always trade.
2. Keep opening the conversation and adding value to the deal by suggesting additional services or things that cost you little, but represent big value to your customer. 
3. Focus on some new goal that you both want in the future and trade your research for their additional business.  RFID is a good example where research and costs can be shared.
4. If the buyer still refuses to budge on getting price reductions, and you are in a stalemate, try escalating the conversation to a C-level executive.  Try organizing a meeting between your executive and your customer’s executive.  Sometimes executives can break the log jam.

Ultimately, if nothing works, you may have to make a difficult decision and part ways with the customer.  It makes no sense to waste your time and valuable resources on unprofitable and unreasonable customers. 

There is a lesson here too, for buyers of 3PL services.  Third Party Logistics is a relatively low-margin business.  When negotiating with your 3PL, remember that they also need to make a profit margin to stay in business.  In negotiations, stubbornness and demanding price concessions with no justification will make you appear uncooperative and a company the 3PL would rather walk away from.



About the Author

image
Rosemary Coates
President of Blue Silk Consulting
Ms. Coates is the Executive Director of the Reshoring Institute and the President of Blue Silk Consulting, a Global Supply Chain consulting firm. She is a best-selling author of: 42 Rules for Sourcing and Manufacturing in China and 42 Rules for Superior Field Service and The Reshoring Guidebook. Ms. Coates lives in Silicon Valley and has worked with over 80 clients worldwide. She is also an Expert Witness for legal cases involving global supply chain matters. She is passionate about Reshoring.

Subscribe to Logistics Management magazine

Subscribe today. It's FREE!
Get timely insider information that you can use to better manage your
entire logistics operation.
Start your FREE subscription today!

Recent Entries

With congestion issues and seaport gridlocks plaguing the transportation industry, air freight volumes are back on the rise. According to JLL’s annual Airport Outlook Report, global air cargo saw a 4.5 percent annual increase in 2014 and the forecast calls for 5 percent growth in 2015.

With a 3.1 cent increase, this week’s average price is $2.811, following last week’s 0.26 cent boost. The gains over the last two weeks come on the heels of a cumulative 16.3 cent decrease over the previous five weeks.

Transportation and logistics bellwether UPS began 2015 in solid fashion with first quarter revenue up 1.4 percent at $14.0 billion and operating profit up 11 percent at $1.7 billion. Earnings per share were up 14 percent at $1.12, which exceeded Wall Street expectations of $1.09, while revenue was shy of the Street’s $14.27 billion estimate.

Last week, the United States Department of Transportation took further steps to address various issues identified in recent train accidents involving crude oil and ethanol shipped by rail. The announcement was made by DOT with other DOT agencies, including the Federal Railroad Administration (FRA) and the Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration (PHMSA).

Logistics Management Group News Editor Jeff Berman had an opportunity to interview Derek Leathers, President and Chief Operating Officer of Werner Enterprises, at this month's NASSTRAC Shippers Conference and Transportation Expo in Orlando. They discussed various aspects of the truckload market, including prices, fuel, and regulations.

Article Topics

Blogs · 3PL · Global · Supply Chain · All topics

About the Author

Patrick Burnson, Executive Editor
Patrick Burnson is executive editor for Logistics Management and Supply Chain Management Review. Patrick covers international trade, global logistics, and supply chain management. He lives and works in San Francisco, providing readers with a Pacific Rim perspective on industry trends and forecasts. Contact Patrick Burnson

Comments

Post a comment
Commenting is not available in this channel entry.