Subscribe to our free, weekly email newsletter!


Supply Chain Technology: There’s power in the cloud

Our contributing technology editor documents how far SaaS has infiltrated the SCM software space and then introduces us to a shipper that’s partnered with its 3PL to leverage a hosted solution that’s managing its domestic and international moves.
By Bridget McCrea, Contributing Editor
March 01, 2011

Not always fluffy
SaaS isn’t all easy. What happens, for example, if the software vendor’s system goes down, leaving the shipper and all of its constituents in a lurch? It can happen, says Adrian Gonzalez, SCM technology analyst and director of Logistics Viewpoints, and it’s something to consider before making the move to a hosted SCM solution.

Gonzalez advises shippers to ask vendors the tough questions like, what happens if your system goes down? What type of backup and recovery methods are in place to ensure that this doesn’t occur? What other risks do I need to be concerned about? “The key is to understand what types of systems and processes your vendor has in place,” says Gonzalez, “and to take these risk-related issues into consideration when you’re shopping around for a solution.”

imageGeography is another challenge, particularly on the TMS side, where many of the SaaS solutions available on the market are U.S.- or North American-centric, says Gonzalez. The shipper who is seeking a single, enterprise-wide, TMS platform that can span multiple geographies, and company divisions should think twice before investing the time and energy in an on-demand TMS, says Gonzalez.

Data integrity issues should also be considered, says Pivar. “Security is one of the biggest things that’s holding SaaS adoption back right now,” he says. Of lesser concern, but still an issue, he adds, are performance issues.

“If you’re relying on a hosting environment and accessing it through the web, that system had better be running in an optimal manner,” says Pivar, who advises shippers to ask for service level guarantees that govern the vendor’s use of proper hardware sizing, as well as the reliability and continuity of the application.

“Shippers want assurances about continuity and security,” says Pivar, who expects SaaS’ popularity to grow, despite those challenges. “Hosted solutions are definitely becoming more mainstream and we expect them to continue to expand,” he says. “I also think that we’re going to see other SCM applications playing in this space, such as warehouse management systems (WMS). There’s no reason why a SaaS model wouldn’t work in that arena.”

Looking past the cloud
Like Pivar, Aimi also sees potential for SaaS in the WMS space, where the concept of running multiple DCs on a single system is fairly new. Because a warehouse exists within “four walls,” says Aimi, the notion that a single, hosted system can handle the activities going on inside is still foreign for most shippers. However, he says the idea that multiple DCs can be connected at an enterprise level through a common system that doesn’t require, say, four different reports from four different facilities, should be a major selling point for the hosted WMS.

And while SaaS still makes the most sense for systems that are inherently network-centric, says Gonzalez, the low upfront investment and faster implementation times afforded by such systems will help drive the hosted software movement across new categories, including WMS.

“If you had asked me a few years ago if SaaS made sense in WMS and ERP, I would have said not as much as it does in TMS and GTM,” says Gonzalez. “However, we’re now seeing some traction in other software areas due to the fact that shippers are looking for quick time-to-value, and/or wanting to replace their existing spreadsheets and fax machines. SaaS could be a good starting place for them.”

Evergreen Packaging: Head in the cloud
When Evergreen Packaging Inc., and Blue Ridge Paper Products Inc., joined to form Evergreen Packaging Group in 2007, it didn’t take long for the new company to get on the growth path.

Soon, the new company realized that it needed to centralize its supply chain and leverage more aspects of its existing transportation network, which was geographically dispersed and fragmented.

David Friedson, director of logistics and distribution for the Memphis-based firm, which makes paperboard packaging solutions that can be found in consumer products like microwavable trays, envelopes, and even lollipop sticks, says the search for a TMS was rooted in the company’s need to centralize its transportation component.

“As the company grew, we realized that our logistics were highly decentralized and taken care of at the facility level,” says Friedson. “We were doing an excellent job handling everything that way, but we really weren’t taking advantage of the complete network that we had in place.”

Evergreen manufactured 15 billion milk and juice cartons in 2009 and served them up to a globally dispersed customer base. Working from nine domestic manufacturing plants and eight more that are located around the globe, the company has a complex supply chain that includes “many different parts and pieces that are moving around the globe at any given time,” says Friedson.

Those moving parts aside, the merger between the two companies and the formation of Evergreen went smoothly. Working in the new company’s favor were the reputations already created by its two predecessors, because both companies had already established themselves as world-class manufacturers, says Friedson. To maximize this unique position—and to make that reputation carry over to the new entity—the firm set its sights on a new logistics strategy that covered both the supply chain execution and the strategies behind it.

The first step involved looking at 10 different supply chain solution providers, according to Friedson, and then narrowing that list down based on a few key criteria. Topping that criteria list were the solution’s value proposition, the client-vendor relationship, the vendor’s knowledge of Evergreen Packaging’s business, as well as the vendor’s project management skills.

Perhaps most importantly, Friedson says that the manufacturer wanted to be able to manage its supply chain on a 24/7, ongoing basis within a dynamic environment that “wasn’t just a static, optimized picture of what had happened in the past, but rather, a look at what was going on during the journey itself.”

After a rigorous selection process that included both on-demand and purchase-and-install options, Evergreen Packaging selected a managed TMS from Transportation Management Center (TMC), a division of C.H. Robinson Worldwide, Inc. Friedson says SaaS was selected after a thorough market search revealed that it would “get us there faster, in terms of really creating value over time and allowing us to focus on strategy, while leaving the execution issues up to the vendor.”

The TMS implementation started in May 2010. Over the eight months that followed, the new system would be rolled out to a total of nine domestic locations, with the last two added in January 2011. “We moved at lightning speed,” says Friedson. “The fast pace alone illustrates just how successful the implementation has been.”

The manufacturer is using the TMC TMS for its North American logistics operations, the bulk of which is handled by truckload and less-than-truckload carriers. The system’s order management component handles all freight-related activities, from tender right on through to payment. “We also use it for business intelligence, to help us improve both our cost and service,” says Friedson. The TMS also captures Evergreen Packaging’s rail transportation activities, although Friedson points out that it’s not being used for the tendering of rail freight.

Because the shipper was previously using a highly fragmented approach to transportation management, there were naturally some cultural issues to work through with the new system. “The challenges were mainly around change management,” says Friedson, who points out the manufacturer’s choice of a hosted solution helped ward off some of those issues right out of the gate.

“Using the hosted model helped us mitigate the change management issue because it allowed us to focus on the change that is going on in our operations, and not worry about how to install and configure a TMS,” says Friedson. “We were able to concentrate on interfacing with the system, and centralizing our transportation management process.”

So far, Evergreen Packaging has seen positive results from its TMS investment with its 3PL. Friedson says carrier performance has improved, although no solid savings or cost cuts have been detected yet. “We’re still in the process of looking at the financial benefits,” says Friedson, who sees hosted solutions as a good bet for shippers of all sizes who are looking to save money and get up and running quickly.

“Compared to the SaaS solutions of 10 years ago, today’s hosted options are fully vetted and very powerful,” says Friedson. “They’re viable options that should be evaluated along with all of the other solutions that are available on today’s market.”


Key processes best suited to cloud computing

Cloud computing is particularly applicable to supply chain activities where extensive customization is not required, or when the activity is performed sporadically (such as a sourcing “event”), or is not a “core” part of what makes the company unique. These activities are likely to be the first to make the transition to the cloud. We will now examine four of them in detail.

1.  Planning and Forecasting: Cloud-based tools are now available for capturing itemized spend data, performing basic analytics, planning manufacturing runs and executing statistical demand forecasts. Applications focused solely on retail supply chains are also prevalent, with capabilities that include planning and allocation, assortment and space, pricing and promotion, and forecasting and replenishment.

In the near future, many more cloud service providers will add planning and forecasting applications to their offering. A primary reason is that planning and forecasting are rarely core components of companies’ ERP systems. This means companies can run one manufacturer’s ERP application internally, while simultaneously leveraging another’s best-of-breed planning/forecasting application via the Internet.

2.  Logistics: Some core warehouse and transportation management applications already are available online from cloud providers. Over the coming years, more and more cloud computing applications for functions such as network strategy, inventory management, warehousing, and transportation will become available. Processes such as global trade compliance, replenishment planning, order processing, transportation load building, fleet management and transportation route planning are likely candidates.

3.  Sourcing & Procurement: Cloud computing represents a great opportunity to reduce total cost of ownership—the most commonly cited success metric in sourcing and procurement. A key reason is that cloud-based tools are inherently collaborative and accessible, creating major benefits for companies that deal routinely with thousands of suppliers. For example, cloud-based collaboration allows multiple parties to jointly develop supplier contracts, dramatically enhancing contract management.

Myriad sourcing and procurement capabilities are rapidly coming online, including procurement report generation, database centralisation and supply chain visibility. Retail potential is particularly strong.

4.  Service and Spare Parts Management: Many companies underperform in service and spare parts management, despite the fact that this area often generates a high proportion of an organization’s profits. Companies can gain significant advantages by using cloud computing to upgrade their capabilities and implement new processes rapidly without extensive capital expenditure costs.

Tools such as warranty validation are already available to service operations, and cloud applications for reverse logistics/returns processing, technician dispatch & tracking, and spare parts inventory pooling & distribution are expected soon.

About the Author

image
Bridget McCrea
Contributing Editor

Bridget McCrea is a Contributing Editor for Logistics Management based in Clearwater, Fla. She has covered the transportation and supply chain space since 1996, and has covered all aspects of the industry for Logistics Management and Supply Chain Management Review. She can be reached at .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address).


Subscribe to Logistics Management magazine

Subscribe today. It's FREE!
Get timely insider information that you can use to better manage your
entire logistics operation.
Start your FREE subscription today!

Recent Entries

As expected, global trade dipped from August to September but still saw annual gains, according to data issued this week by Panjiva, an online search engine with detailed information on global suppliers and manufacturers.

Transportation and logistics merger and acquisition (M&A) activity in the third quarter saw annual gains, which were driven by smaller deals in the trucking logistics, shipping, and passenger air sectors, according to data issued in the Intersections report by PwC this week.

With the holidays rapidly approaching, it appears retailers are not quite done getting inventory set up and on the shelves in time for what is expected to be a fairly active shopping season. That much was evident based on recent data for September volumes issued by the Port of Los Angeles (POLA) and the Port of Long Beach (POLB).

Join Industry Expert Adrian Gonzalez for this educational webinar on the tenets and the benefits of Closed-Loop Operational Management. You’ll learn how Closed-Loop Operational Management optimizes orders, inventory, and transportation concurrently, and how it is able to optimize large-scale problems on a daily basis.

In a separate conference call following CP’s third quarter earnings release call yesterday, CP CEO Hunter Harrison make myriad convincing points for a merger between CP and CSX and offered up his take in general industry M&A as well.

Comments

Post a comment
Commenting is not available in this channel entry.


© Copyright 2013 Peerless Media LLC, a division of EH Publishing, Inc • 111 Speen Street, Ste 200, Framingham, MA 01701 USA