Various factors spur declines in Class I railroads 2016 capital expenditure projections

While the investments are beyond impressive, 2016 capital expenditure investments rolled out by Class I railroads in recent weeks paint a picture of lower annual spending levels compared to past years.

Transportation in the News

Some shipping sectors still slow to recognize advances in ocean cargo technology
New Report Says Global Ocean Cargo Industry at the “Tipping Point” of Digitization
ATA reports a decent bounce back month for truck tonnage in May
Logistics costs fall for first time since Great Recession, new report says
U.S-bound waterborne shipments remain steady in May, reports Panjiva
More Transportation News

Transportation Resource

Making the Case: A Modern-Day Transportation Management System
The modern day supply chain has become a competitive tool for companies of all sizes and across all industries. At the same time, the transportation industry looks drastically different than it did 20 years ago, when most transportation management systems (TMS) were originally designed.
All Resources
By ·

For several years, the amount of annual capital expenditures made by freight railroads into things like upgraded track, new locomotives, and freight cars, among others, could be viewed as staggering.

Why staggering? There are a few ways to explain it, but some perspective is needed to digest the capital commitments these carriers are making each and every year. Perhaps the best way to view it is through the lens provided by the Association of American Railroads (AAR).

The AAR says that freight railroads spend 18 percent of their revenues on capital investment compared to 3 percent invested by the average U.S. manufacturer. That is quite a spread there and it really speaks to the steep levels of investments being made into railroad networks every year.

As previously reported in LM, for 2015 the AAR said that freight railroads spent an estimated $29 billion on the country’s rail network, ahead of 2014’s $27 billion, which equates to roughly $79 million a day, while bringing the total investment made by freight railroads going back to 1980 to $575 billion.

While these investments are beyond impressive, 2016 capital expenditure investments rolled out by Class I railroads in recent weeks paint a picture of lower annual spending levels compared to past years.

A quick look at the data issued by the seven Class I railroads bears that out, too, based on these figures below:
-CSX, $2.4 billion in 2016 and $3.4 billion in 2015;
-BNSF, $4.3 billion in 2016 and $5.8 billion in 2015;
-Union Pacific, $3.75 billion in 2016 and $4.3 billion in 2015;
-KCS, $580-to-$590 million in 2016 and $649 million in 2015;
-Canadian Pacific, $1.1 billion in 2016 and $1.5 billion in 2015;
-CN, $2.9 billion in 2016 and $2.7 billion in 2015 (the lone carrier expecting an increase); and
-Norfolk Southern, $2.1 billion in 2016 and $2.4 billion in 2015

These decreases in what are still very impressive spending figures reflect a railroad and intermodal market that from a volume, and, in some cases revenue and net income, perspective. United States rail carloads in 2015, for example, were down 6.1 percent annually, with total carload and intermodal volumes down 2.5 percent.

To be sure, these volume declines are a byproduct of issues in some key sectors served by freight railroads, with coal’s ongoing steep declines still front and center. 

And that by no means suggests that even with volumes down in 2015, followed by reduced 2016 capital expenditure plans, that the Class I’s are in free fall by any stretch. Instead, it speaks to being able to get expenses in line with what is happening on the front lines, as well as planning for the future, too. Would anyone be surprised to see 2017 capital expenditures set a new record, with 2016 being viewed as, to borrow a sports term, “a bridge year?” Hardly, I think, but at the same time 2016 is basically in the first inning still and there is a lot of the game still to play.

But before jumping to conclusions it is wise to look at the factors that led to the 2016 capital expenditure declines, which were succinctly outlined by Brooks Bentz, president of Transplace Consulting Services. 

“The rail industry’s rapid resurgence was continuing at a strong pace, despite the decline in coal loadings, largely buoyed by oil and related commodities (e.g., frack sand, pipe, etc.) and strong growth in the automotive sector and sustained growth in intermodal,” Bentz said. “The rapid rise in the cost of oil only a short time ago, enabled the extensive development of the domestic oil patch.  With the bottom falling out of the per-barrel cost of Middle East oil, the profitability of domestic production crashed with a loud bang.  So, when you put that together with the continuing decline in coal, it’s a significant drain on revenue and profitability that simply can’t be made up easily, if at all.  On top of that, the declining cost of oil and resulting ‘cheap’ diesel fuel has dissipated the increasing advantage intermodal was reaping over OTR trucking.  The next result of that has been a ‘re-diversion’ of traffic back to OTR from intermodal and sluggish or declining intermodal volumes.”

And Bentz added that maintaining the capital investment programs that were on the books just isn’t feasible, with what he called “inevitable cutbacks” appearing, which is just good economic sense, under the current circumstances. 

But at the same time he made it clear that does not change the long-term need for sustained investment in infrastructure and capacity expansion, as other issues, such as highway congestion will still contribute to sector growth.  Instead, he explained, the question will be how long this will last, what the options might be and at what level will the Class I’s be able to continue to invest if the current predicament persists with no relief?

These are questions with no easy answers at the moment, but given the proven track records freight railroads have demonstrated over the years, especially when considering they are on the hook for all of their capital investments, it stands to reason they will assess the situation and react accordingly and wisely in the form of measured and calculated capital expenditures investments. 

About the Author

Jeff Berman, Group News Editor
Jeff Berman is Group News Editor for Logistics Management, Modern Materials Handling, and Supply Chain Management Review. Jeff works and lives in Cape Elizabeth, Maine, where he covers all aspects of the supply chain, logistics, freight transportation, and materials handling sectors on a daily basis. Contact Jeff Berman

Subscribe to Logistics Management Magazine!

Subscribe today. It's FREE!
Get timely insider information that you can use to better manage your entire logistics operation.
Start your FREE subscription today!

Article Topics

AAR · Carload · Class I Railroad · Intermodal · All Topics
Latest Whitepaper
Digital Issue: The Current State of Third-Party Logistics Services
It has become quite clear that logistics professionals are now facing an unprecedented set of challenges. From tightening capacity, to ongoing regulation hurdles, to the complexity brought on by e-commerce, today’s shippers are transforming the way they manage their logistics operations.
Download Today!
From the June 2017 Issue
Here are five trends that every shipper­—and potential shipper—must watch as the demand for experienced logistics and supply chain professionals soars.
2017 Rail/Intermodal Roundtable: Volume stable, business steady
Cross-Border Logistics: NAFTA tune-up time
View More From this Issue
Subscribe to Our Email Newsletter
Sign up today to receive our FREE, weekly email newsletter!
Latest Webcast
Women in Logistics: Breaking Gender Roles to Win the War for Talent
In this session you'll hear from a panel of women who are now leading top-level logistics and supply chain operations. The panel will share their success stories as well as advice for women who are now making their way up the ladder.
Register Today!
2017 Top 50 3PLs: Investment and Consolidation Maintain Traction
The trend set over the past few years for mergers and acquisitions has hardly subsided, and a fresh...
The Evolution of the Digital Supply Chain
Everyone is talking about terms like digitization, Industry 4.0 and digital supply chain management,...

2017 Salary Survey: Fresh Voices Express Optimism
Our “33rd Annual Salary Survey” reflects more diversity entering the logistics management...
LM Exclusive: Major Modes Join E-commerce Mix
While last mile carriers receive much of the attention, the traditional modal heavyweights are in...