Subscribe to our free, weekly email newsletter!


Andreoli on Oil and Fuel: Diesel/natural gas price differential narrowed in first half of 2013

By Derik Andreoli
August 01, 2013

One needs to look no further than the futures market for evidence that analysts’ forecasts are rarely correct. In every trade, the buyer believes that prices will rise, and the seller believes the exact opposite. Not often do you see an analyst publicly reflect on a prior forecast—except, of course, when their goal is to make a “victory lap.”

There is value, however, in revisiting forecasts because critical reflection helps the analyst to refine assumptions and provides insight into complex relationships between dynamic variables.

As individuals we do this regularly in everyday life. For example, I was recently introduced to archery. Only after purchasing all the equipment did I learn that the system of shooter, bow, and arrow is significantly complex—and that the particular arrows I purchased were too stiff for my bow. Through research I came to understand the complexity of the system; and this, in turn, allowed me to troubleshoot the problem.

Oil and natural gas markets are similarly complex, and predicting precisely where oil and gas prices are going to be at some predetermined point in the future could be accurately described as a fool’s errand. However, it’s an essential exercise for anyone who is considering investment in natural gas powered trucks.

Luckily for analysts like me, success in forecasting is graded on a curve. Hitting the target consistently is worth something even if the arrow does not regularly find the bull’s-eye.

Over the last year and a half, the domestic natural gas market has been a frequent topic covered in this column. I have consistently asserted that the extremely low prices are transitory, though the timing and the magnitude of the inevitable price increase remain stubbornly elusive. At the beginning of the year I forecasted that the price differential would narrow as natural gas prices rise and diesel prices remain flat.

On the diesel side, my forecast is rooted in a complex model designed to predict global surplus oil production capacity. This model allows various supply and demand scenarios to be evaluated. And under the most likely set of macroeconomic conditions, surplus production capacity was expected to increase moderately through the year. This increase was expected to be high enough to reduce price volatility, but not high enough to bring prices down. This forecast proved to be right for the right reasons. Consider that a “victory lap.”

The domestic natural gas market is significantly more complex than oil and diesel markets, and there are a large number of important “unknowable unknowns.” The most important of which is the marginal cost to produce a unit of natural gas through hydraulic fracturing.

Estimates of breakeven prices range from $4.70 per Mcf for wells with low production decline rates to $9.00 per well for wells with high decline rates or low initial flow rates.

At the beginning of the year, the second important “unknowable unknown” was the staying power of the natural gas glut, which pushed prices down from $5.69 per Mcf in January 2010 to $1.89 per Mcf by April 2012. At the time, the trend in rig counts provided strong indication that the glut would be temporary. Rig counts had declined nearly 50 percent, from 811 in January 2012 to 429 in January 2013.

According to the data crunchers at the Energy Information Administration, “the average spot natural gas prices at most major trading points increased 40 percent to 60 percent during the first half of 2013 compared to the same period in 2012.” Two processes are at work here: Low prices have caused growth in supply to slow and growth in demand to accelerate.

While my arrow clearly hit the target—natural gas prices increased as predicted—my aim was high. I had expected prices to rise north of $5 per Mcf, but the average price only just barely broke $4 per Mcf for a brief period, and over the first half of 2013 averaged only $3.75. With hindsight, I see that in my analysis, I had overestimated the slowdown of supply growth.

Looking forward, I expect the diesel/natural gas price differential to continue to contract through the end of the year. On the natural gas side, rig counts have averaged just 355 over the last three months. By comparison, 1,461 rigs were drilling for natural gas in April 2008.

On the diesel side, oil production in the U.S. and Iraq continues to grow rapidly while emerging market demand will continue its lackluster performance.

Learning from my earlier forecast, I expect natural gas prices to average $4 to $4.25 per Mcf through the second half of the year. At this price level the incentive to drill new wells will remain slight. Consequently, there is a possibility for a dramatic reversal in gas storage from relative glut to scarcity sometime over the next 12 months.

About the Author

Derik Andreoli

Derik Andreoli, Ph.D.c. is the Senior Analyst at Mercator International, LLC. He welcomes any comments or questions, and can be contacted at .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address).


Subscribe to Logistics Management magazine

Subscribe today. It's FREE!
Get timely insider information that you can use to better manage your
entire logistics operation.
Start your FREE subscription today!

Recent Entries

Last week, the United States Department of Transportation took further steps to address various issues identified in recent train accidents involving crude oil and ethanol shipped by rail. The announcement was made by DOT with other DOT agencies, including the Federal Railroad Administration (FRA) and the Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration (PHMSA).

Logistics Management Group News Editor Jeff Berman had an opportunity to interview Derek Leathers, President and Chief Operating Officer of Werner Enterprises, at this month's NASSTRAC Shippers Conference and Transportation Expo in Orlando. They discussed various aspects of the truckload market, including prices, fuel, and regulations.

During this webcast our presenters will apply the findings of the 23rd Annual Trends & Issues in Transportation and Logistics Study to the world of shipper-carrier decision making. They'll examine the primary aspects that will influence the future direction for shipper-carrier decision-making.

For February, the month for which most recent data is available, the SCI dropped to -1.0 from January’s 2.6, with FTR explaining that the short term positive impact from one-time adjustments for rapidly dropping diesel prices and the suspension of the 2013 motor carriers hours-of-service expires later this year.

Seasonally-adjusted (SA) for-hire truck tonnage in March was up 1.1 percent on the heels of a revised 2.8 percent (from 3.1 percent) February decline, with the SA index at 133.5 (2000=100). This is off 0.3 percent from the all-time high for the SA of 135.8 from January 2015 and is up 5 percent annually.

Comments

Post a comment
Commenting is not available in this channel entry.


© Copyright 2015 Peerless Media LLC, a division of EH Publishing, Inc • 111 Speen Street, Ste 200, Framingham, MA 01701 USA